A new website is supposed to bring in more business. Sometimes it does the opposite: the new site launches, looks great, and within a few weeks the enquiries from Google have dropped by half. The design isn't usually the cause. Something about the site's structure changed during the rebuild, and Google lost track of pages it used to rank.
The good news is that this is almost always preventable. Here's the checklist we work through on every redesign.
Before You Start: Record What You Have
You can't protect rankings you haven't recorded. Before any design work begins:
- Export every URL on the current site. A crawler such as Screaming Frog will list them all, along with page titles and descriptions.
- Find out which pages bring in traffic. Google Search Console shows which pages get clicks and which search terms they rank for. Export at least the last 12 months.
- Note which pages other sites link to. Links from other websites are valuable, and they point at specific URLs. Search Console's Links report and tools like Ahrefs or Semrush will show them.
This gives you a list of the pages that matter. Those pages need the most care.
Keep URLs Where You Can
The simplest way to protect a page's rankings is not to change its address. If /services/tax-advice ranks well, keep it at /services/tax-advice on the new site, even if the new navigation is organized differently.
When a URL has to change, which is common when moving platforms, it needs a redirect.
Redirect Every Old URL That Matters
A 301 redirect tells browsers and Google that a page has moved permanently, and passes most of the old page's ranking value to the new address. Without one, the old URL returns a "page not found" error and its rankings disappear.
Build a redirect map: a spreadsheet with every old URL in one column and its new home in the other. Rules for this map:
- Redirect each old page to the most relevant new page, not to the homepage. Sending everything to the homepage is treated by Google much like a missing page.
- Avoid chains (A to B to C). Redirect straight to the final address.
- Include old URLs that still get links from other sites, even if the pages themselves were removed long ago.
Don't Throw Away Content That Ranks
Redesigns often come with a push to make pages shorter and cleaner. That's fine for most pages, but if a page ranks well because it thoroughly answers a question, cutting it to three sentences can cost you the ranking.
Look at your top traffic pages before rewriting them. Improve them, but keep the substance that made them rank.
Carry Over the SEO Details
Check that each important page keeps or improves:
- Its title tag and meta description
- Its main heading
- Structured data, such as product, review, FAQ or local business markup
- Image alt text
- Internal links pointing to it from other pages on the site
Internal links are easy to lose in a redesign. If ten pages used to link to your best service page and now only the menu does, Google may see that page as less important.
The Launch-Day Mistake
The most common cause of a sudden drop is also the simplest. While a new site is being built, it's usually hidden from Google with a "noindex" setting or a blocking rule in the robots.txt file. If that setting goes live with the site, Google is told to stop indexing it.
On launch day, check:
- The robots.txt file doesn't block the site
- Pages don't carry a noindex tag
- The XML sitemap is live, lists the new URLs, and has been submitted in Search Console
- The redirects actually work (test a sample of old URLs)
- Analytics and Search Console are tracking the new site
After Launch: Watch Closely
Some movement in rankings for a few weeks after launch is normal while Google processes the changes. For the first month or two:
- Check Search Console's Pages report for new "not found" errors and add redirects for them
- Compare clicks and impressions for your key pages against the numbers you recorded before launch
- Keep the old redirects in place permanently
If traffic hasn't recovered after six to eight weeks, something structural is usually still wrong, and the records you made before launch are what will help you find it.
Plan It From the Start
SEO protection is much easier to build into a redesign than to bolt on afterwards. If you're planning a new site and the current one brings in meaningful traffic from Google, mention it at the start of the project.
We handle redirect mapping and launch checks as part of our website builds, and our SEO services cover recovery if a past redesign has already cost you rankings. Get in touch if you'd like us to look at your situation.
